A Californian Court of Appeal has ruled Amazon is With You Againresponsible for defective products sold through its Marketplace, even if they are being sold by a third party. This decision has significant implications for Amazon, which had previously managed to avoid liability by claiming it is merely a service provider.
"Whatever term we use to describe Amazon’s role, be it 'retailer,' 'distributor,' or merely 'facilitator,' it was pivotal in bringing the product here to the consumer," Justice Patricia Guerrero said in her ruling. "Under established principles of strict liability, Amazon should be held liable if a product sold through its website turns out to be defective."
Strict liability is a legal standard that holds people responsible for injury caused by their actions, even if there was no fault or malicious intent involved.
The court's finding overturns a San Diego Superior Court decision from last year. The case concerned San Diego woman Angela Bolger, who used Amazon to buy a replacement laptop battery from an Amazon seller listed as "E-Life" — a pseudonym for Lenoge Technology (HK) Ltd. Several months after Bolger received the battery it exploded, inflicting her with severe burns.
Bolger sued Amazon, which successfully argued that it couldn't be held accountable because it only provides an online marketplace service, and didn't manufacture, distribute, or sell the battery to her.
However, the Court of Appeal has found that while the battery was not Amazon-branded, the company's involvement went beyond that of a mere online marketplace such as eBay, as Amazon handled payment and shipping as well as stored the battery in one of its warehouses.
SEE ALSO: Amazon’s Echo Buds are overheating, so you should update your software now"Amazon accepted possession of the product from Lenoge, stored it in an Amazon warehouse, attracted Bolger to the Amazon website, provided her with a product listing for Lenoge’s product, received her payment for the product, and shipped the product in Amazon packaging to her," said Guerrero. "Amazon set the terms of its relationship with Lenoge, controlled the conditions of Lenoge’s offer for sale on Amazon, limited Lenoge’s access to Amazon’s customer information, forced Lenoge to communicate with customers through Amazon, and demanded indemnification as well as substantial fees on each purchase."
"Amazon is a direct link in the chain of distribution, acting as a powerful intermediary between the third-party seller and the consumer," Guerrero continued. "Bolger’s claims are based on Amazon’s role in the chain of production and distribution of an allegedly defective product."
The decision follows a previous ruling by the Philadelphia Court of Appeal last year, which also found Amazon could be held liable for defects in third-party products. Such findings open Amazon up to a myriad of complaints from customers seeking redress for defective third-party products — lawsuits Amazon no doubt would rather avoid.
An Amazon spokesperson told Mashable in a statement that the company will be filing an appeal.
"The court's decision was wrongly decided and is contrary to well-established law in California and around the country that service providers are not liable for third party products they do not make or sell," said the spokesperson. "We will appeal this decision."
UPDATE: Aug. 15, 2020, 6:40 a.m. AEST Amazon responded to Mashable's request for comment, which has been added at the foot of this story.
Topics Amazon
The Best Gaming Concept Art of 2016
First look at Windows Story Remix, the app that turns anyone into a Hollywood director
'American Gods' is blessed with a Season 2 renewal after two episodes
'Prey' exploit lets players break the game
NYT Connections Sports Edition hints and answers for May 19: Tips to solve Connections #238
UK startup Improbable just raised half a billion dollars to build the Matrix
J.K. Rowling sends heartfelt tweet to fans after rare 'Harry Potter' prequel is stolen
NES Classic is dead, but there's a new way to play Nintendo in HD
What cracked the Milky Way's giant cosmic bone? Scientists think they know.
The laptop ban could expand to flights coming from Europe
SpaceX's Starlink satellite launch in pictures
United tries to join in with viral nugget tweet, gets savagely roasted
'Avocado hand' is real and can turn your dream brunch into an ER nightmare
Spring raises $65 million to fund a shopping mall on your smartphone
A Typical Wall Street Republican
This guy makes amazing coffee art that is seriously next level
Watch: Heath Ledger's sister 'screamed and cried' watching new documentary
Steve Harvey does NOT want anyone coming into his dressing room
Gods of War
We are what we wear — and that matters a lot in job interviews
Are Machines Changing Translation from an Art to a Science?iPhone 15 Pro overheating reports pop up around the internetThe Enlightenment Is Like a Centaur—and We Must Kill It!Shrek's swamp is coming to Airbnb'The Office' reboot is a good idea — if Michael, Jim, Dwight, and Pam aren't in itOn Taylor Swift’s PassiveDid the Erie Canal Change Our Vowel Sounds?Peloton will reportedly halt making... basically everything, including all its bikes and treadsVideo and audio calls on X, formerly Twitter, will be for paying subscribers onlyTwitter is listing famous families that would only get 4 free COVIDWatch Bill Murray's surprise musical performance in an NYC parkWordle today: Here's the answer and hints for September 25obé has over 7,000 live and onOn Taylor Swift’s Passive'Quordle' today: See each 'Quordle' answer and hints for September 26, 2023EighteenthAt the Newsstand, Chivalry Is Most Surely Not Dead'The Office' reboot is a good idea — if Michael, Jim, Dwight, and Pam aren't in itSouvenirs of a Life: Collages by John Ashbery & Guy MaddinWordle today: Here's the answer and hints for September 25 Critics heap praise upon 'Fifty Shades Darker' Alex Jones' chemtrails theory gets a 'DuckTales' remix, finally? Meet the architect behind China's smog Wind power is now the top clean energy source in the U.S. 'Stranger Things' reveals Season 2 plot details, where the characters are now Wow, this gang of squirrel monkey babies is very adorable There's a new Hyperloop company, and its leader is a familiar face Apple CEO Tim Cook: Tech companies have to fight fake news Well, looks like Karlie Kloss thinks 'Waterfalls' is a Destiny's Child song Ferocious blizzard smacks New York, but it'll be over sooner than you think A bunch of people bought shares in a company that they thought was Snapchat Astronaut captures clearest footage yet of rare type of lightning Bryan Cranston almost smacked Tony Parker's butt to get $100 from M. Night Shyamalan New children's book tells the story of iconic artist and activist Keith Haring Teenagers spot fire on plane flying overhead, avert major disaster NBA becomes first sports league to create a gaming league Japan is rolling out these hilariously obvious signs to help clueless tourists Samsung Chromebook Plus review Scottish comedian pens hilarious yet brutal piece about Trump Twitter's in a tailspin. Will it take flight, or embrace the fail whale of fate?
1.9785s , 8223.6640625 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【With You Again】,Feast Information Network